Doctrine Status in v4

Where each core construct stands in v4, and what changed from v3.6.

Last updated 1 November 2026, against doctrine v4. v3.6 is superseded by v4; it was not ratified. The changelog carries the dated history.

The core constructs in v4.
Constructv4 status
Law 1, Agents Are Identities, Not ToolsRetained; body revised.
Law 2, Enforce at RuntimeMajor change. Re-scoped from control during execution to protected enforcement before each effect, with pre-commit rechecks when material conditions can change.
Law 3, Governance Must Span SystemsRetained; body revised.
Law 4, Trust Does Not TravelRetained; body revised.
Law 5, Humans Retain the Right to InterveneRetained; body revised.
Least AgencyRetained, including the zero case: the mission owner first decides whether autonomous decision-making is warranted.
The Architecture, five PlanesCount retained; bodies revised.
The Framework, six PillarsCount retained.
Mandatory runtime baseline R01 to R18New in v4.
Assessment Companion R19 to R24New in v4.
Organizational maturity evaluationReplaces the v3.6 Maturity Model. Rated by dimension; separate from any deployment and does not license one.
RFC 001, the Conformance LayerHistorical proposal, preserved. Not adopted text.

A change is major, and issues a new major version, when it alters the text or meaning of a Law, the Planes or Pillars, or the scope of the mandatory runtime baseline. Feedback is accepted at any time; the Institute reviews it and the Executive Director releases minor versions.